Killaloe Council speaks out on wind issue

January 15, 2009 at 1:10 pm Leave a comment

Killaloe, Hagarty and Richards asks province to impose moratorium on wind turbine projects

The reading of a resolution at a special meeting in the council chambers of Killaloe, Hagarty and Richards Township prompted applause from the large audience in attendance last week. The resolution requests the Province of Ontario to impose a 10-year moratorium on all industrial wind turbine projects under consideration until new medical, economic and environmental studies are reviewed; it also resolved that local municipalities retain the authority to control and direct industrial wind turbine development in their individual municipalities. 
Council arranged the public meeting after receiving Notice of Applications – to amend the County of Renfrew Official Plan to allow wind energy farms on subject lands – from the municipalities of Brudenell, Lyndoch and Raglan and Madawaska Valley. 
“This is a very controversial issue,” said Mayor Janice Visneskie in her opening remarks. 
Over the past year, the township has received a wealth of information for and against wind projects. 
“We have made it our goal to get all sides of the issue,” she said. 
Council has instructed the roads committee, headed by Carl Kuehl, to review the municipality’s roads bylaw to see what can be done to tighten weight load conditions without harming all businesses that use the roads. 
“There are no wind farms proposed for K, H and R, but they may have to use our roads,” said Visneskie. “We have to do something to ensure our roads are not damaged.” 
Lou Eyamie, president of S.O.S. (Save Our Skylines) told council he understood that a transformer would be located in Killaloe, Hagarty and Richards. This was news to council. 
“We have not heard about a transformer in K, H and R,” said Visneskie. 
Nelson Coulas told council he’d heard of a lawsuit in the Kingston area over the effects of a transformer located near a man’s property. Brian Tyrrell told the story of a man living next to a transformer who had his property assessment reduced 50 per cent by the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation. 
“He’s planning to go back to MPAC and see if he can get it knocked down to zero,” Tyrrell added, which prompted Councillor Carl Kuehl to respond jokingly, “Don’t say that – everyone will want a transformer next door to get a zero assessment.” 
Local resident Garnet Kranz, who has property in Brudenell, Lyndoch and Raglan, expressed concern over the “stroboscopic effect” that generators situated within a half-kilometre of the 16th Concession would have along the road. 
Councillor Kathy Marion wanted to know what financial benefit municipalities receive from wind projects. Visneskie told her that, on a council-sanctioned trip to visit wind projects in Sault Ste. Marie and Shelburne, she spoke with the reeve of Prince Township (just outside the Soo), and was told the township “got a good deal. The reeve said he would welcome even more turbines.” She said she’d heard that the municipality at Shelburne also received an economic benefit. 
“Municipalities are facing tough times, but they don’t want to raise taxes,” she said. “So I can see why municipalities are looking at this.” 
Visneskie said she was told that all power generated at the Prince Wind Farm goes to Toronto and not to the Soo; she was also told that if there is too much wind, the turbines have to be shut down. 
“If they’re not reliable, why are we looking at this?” she said. She was told that the companies get green grants from the federal government; they also get green tax breaks and are allowed to “sell” their Kyoto points. 
Tyrrell said a major polluter in the United States could buy the company, thereby getting the carbon offsets. 
“Ontario gets to look green and we get all the disadvantages,” he said. 
Discussion turned to moratoriums. Marion expressed concern about the financial stability of wind turbine companies, but was not sure a moratorium was the way to go. Councillor Ernie Cybulski was afraid a 10-year moratorium would not be long enough. He referred to the Blue Box program, stating the province was behind it at first, “but then they said ‘Oops we want out.’ It’s the same with MTO (Ministry of Transport) – they used to look after all the highways then downloaded many of them. Will this happen with wind turbines down the road? Will we end up looking after them when they break down?” 
Councillor Stanley Pecoskie brought up a 10-year moratorium recently passed by the Township of South Algonquin Council. 
“Most of the land in question is Crown land, so will the moratorium mean anything? A moratorium may work for part of our municipality, but about 93 per cent of Richards township is Crown land and we wouldn’t have a say on it.” 
Visneskie said council could “object, and deny, but they have the right to go to an OMB (Ontario Municipal Board) hearing and we could lose. I don’t want anyone to think this council has the capability to shut them down. We can put roadblocks in place, but it’s up to the taxpayers to be vocal.” 
At this point in the meeting, councillors agreed to write up a motion. Following a break to allow Councillor Debbie Peplinskie and CAO/Clerk Lorna Hudder time to write the document, Visneskie read the resolution aloud. When she finished, her words were met with loud applause. 
Nelson Coulas, who has property close to one of the proposed projects, said he was born in Killaloe. 
“This council makes me proud of the direction it’s heading in trying to keep everyone safe. I’m proud to come from Killaloe. I have faith that Brudenell, Lyndoch and Raglan will do the right thing too.” 
Visneskie introduced the motion to council and it was passed in a unanimous, recorded vote. The township will send a copy of the resolution to Madawaska Valley and Brudenell, Lyndoch and Raglan along with a covering letter explaining its decision. Visneskie thanked the councillors for “being proactive, open and for making solid decisions. They took the time to carefully look at this issue. Congrats to Debbie and Lorna for drafting the motion. Well done.” 
By Heather Kendall 
Barry’s Bay This Week 
14 January 2009


Entry filed under: Uncategorized.

Ontario eyes speeding up wind turbine approvals Bonnechere Valley Council receives letter from resident

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

RSS National Wind Watch

  • Town of Parishville not interested in PILOTS from wind farms; board passes local wind law establishing setbacks, sound output limits #NY June 28, 2017
    PARISHVILLE – The Parishville Town Board unanimously passed a local wind law at their meeting June 22 establishing wind turbine setbacks and sound output limits. However, the town is not interested in payments in lieu of taxes – PILOTS – from a large-scale wind power project planned to be built by Avangrid Renewables. The proposed wind farm has divided the P […]
    National Wind Watch
  • Six windfarms investigated for alleged planning irregularity #IRL June 28, 2017
    Six windfarms are under investigation by Cork County Council for alleged planning irregularities, amid calls from councillors for the Government to tighten up the industry. In a report presented to councillors, Paul Murphy, the local authority’s senior planner, said that of the 20 windfarms built so far in the county, six are being investigated on foot of co […]
    National Wind Watch
  • St. Lawrence County considers PILOT policy for wind farms #NY June 28, 2017
    CANTON – Large-scale wind developers who receive payment-in-lieu-of-taxes agreements will be required to make payments equal to what they would pay in property taxes, according to a policy being considered by St. Lawrence County legislators. The policy was approved Monday night by the Finance Committee, but won’t be final until it’s voted on July 10 by the f […]
    National Wind Watch
  • $4.2 billion wind stymied in Ohio: House refuses to ease restrictive zoning #OH June 28, 2017
    CLEVELAND – Ohio lawmakers are not going to allow electric utilities to seek rate increases solely to buttress sagging credit ratings, as requested by one state utility And they are shutting the door on more than $4.2 billion in new wind farm investment that has been blocked by restrictive state zoning requirements enacted three years ago. These two unrelate […]
    National Wind Watch
  • Falmouth selectmen weigh financial impact of turbine shutdown #MA June 28, 2017
    FALMOUTH – After huddling in a closed-door session for more than 2½ hours Monday night, figuring out whether they would abide by a judge’s decision last week to keep the town’s two mammoth wind turbines at the wastewater treatment plant shut down or fight on via an appeal, the selectmen announced they needed more information “because of the potential financi […]
    National Wind Watch
  • With wind farm moratorium, renewable energy deal in doubt #NC June 28, 2017
    RALEIGH, N.C. – The future of legislation agreed upon by renewable energy interests and Duke Energy to extend the utility’s requirements to use more alternative power in North Carolina is in doubt as a key senator repeats his attempts to delay wind energy permits through 2020. The bill to change how the nation’s largest electric utility purchases electricity […]
    National Wind Watch
  • Wind company to cover costs of road damages in West Lincoln #ON June 28, 2017
    WEST LINCOLN – The deal has yet to close, but town council is already in a quandary over how to spend funds they expect to receive from the Niagara Region Wind Farm for damage it caused to municipal roads during construction. While it remains unclear what the final sum is that they expect to receive, on Monday night West Lincoln councillors considered roadwo […]
    National Wind Watch
  • Michigan’s wind energy farms whip up plenty of praise and complaints #MI June 28, 2017
    SAGINAW, MI – In the past decade, rural landscapes in the Thumb and elsewhere in Michigan have been radically altered by the advent of utility-scale wind farms. Even if you haven’t seen wind turbines towering over farmland, you might have seen the trucks hauling massive, white turbine blades on freeways. Up close, the whirling blades of wind turbines stretch […]
    National Wind Watch
  • Plans submitted for 21 turbine wind farm in Sutherland #SCT June 28, 2017
    Plans are being set in motion for a new 21 turbine wind farm in Sutherland. A partnership comprising members of the agricultural sector is proposing to build Meall Buidhe on the Croick Estate, near Ardgay. If given approval, it will be situated approximately five miles from the operational Rosehall and Achany wind farms and six miles from the proposed Braemo […]
    National Wind Watch
  • 160-foot wind turbine blade snaps, dangles from rotor #MI June 27, 2017
    BLUMFIELD TWP, MI – The 160-foot blade of a wind turbine broke from its rotor Monday morning in rural Saginaw County and is now left dangling. Workers were alerted to the break when the wind turbine went offline Monday morning, June 26, said Bryan Garner, a spokesperson for NextEra Energy Resources. Investigators believe the break was caused by an equipment […]
    National Wind Watch

%d bloggers like this: